5 Ways to Turn Your Family Photos Into a Holiday Card People Actually Keep

posted on

October 28, 2026

Kimberly Ayars

posted by

filed in

Every December, a fresh batch of holiday cards lands in mailboxes across Geneva, Batavia, and St. Charles. Some get a quick glance and end up in the recycling bin by January 2nd. Others get taped to the fridge and stay there until, well, October. (Yes, I still have some up. No, I’m not apologizing.) The difference between those two piles has very little to do with fancy outfits or a perfectly coordinated color palette. It has everything to do with how the session was approached from the very beginning. Here are my favorite tips for holiday card family photos.

If you’re thinking about using your family photos for a holiday card this year, these five things will help you get there.


The Cards People Save Look Nothing Like What You’d Expect

Here’s what I’ve noticed after photographing a lot of families: the cards that end up staying on display are almost never the stiff, everyone-look-at-the-camera ones. The cards people save are the ones where a family looks genuinely relaxed, like they’re actually enjoying being together.

I think about one session in particular where we threw out the traditional approach entirely and reenacted those wonderfully awkward family photos – the kind you’d find in a 1994 JCPenney catalog. It was so fun! Everyone was laughing, nobody was overthinking it, and that family told me afterward it was probably their best Christmas card ever.

That’s the thing about organic posing. When you’re looking at each other, interacting, and laughing together, something real comes through in the photo. That’s what makes people stop and actually look at a card instead of just glancing past it.


Tell Your Photographer Upfront That a Holiday Card Is the Goal

This is probably the tip I wish more families knew before they booked. If a holiday card is on your radar, say so from the start.

When I know that’s the plan, I can make sure we capture:

  • Full family shots that work well as a single card image
  • Separate photos of just the kids in case you want options
  • A photo of just the parents – because yes, you deserve to be in the card too, and not just as background characters holding a baby

Knowing your end goal shapes how I approach the whole session. It’s a simple thing to mention upfront, but it changes everything about how we plan your time together.


Decide Before the Session: One Photo or a Collage?

This is a question I genuinely wish more families thought about ahead of time. There are two very different approaches to a holiday card, and they require slightly different things from your session.

  • One hero image: You want one strong, card-worthy photo that captures everybody at their best. This means we focus energy on getting that full-family moment just right.
  • A collage layout: You want several photos that tell a little story together. This opens up more creative options and gives you flexibility – but it also means we want to capture a variety of shots, angles, and groupings.

Neither approach is better than the other. But knowing which direction you’re leaning before your session means we can work toward that goal together instead of figuring it out after the fact.


Let Go of the Pressure to Be Perfect

I’ll say it plainly: the pressure to get “the perfect shot” for a holiday card is one of the biggest things that works against families during a session.

When everyone is tense and trying hard to look a certain way, it shows. Stiff poses, forced smiles, kids who can feel the stress and respond accordingly. The photos that result from that energy tend to be the forgettable ones.

The cards worth keeping? They come from sessions where families let themselves just… be. Where someone cracks a joke at the wrong moment, where a kid does something unexpected, where the parents share a look that says “yep, this is our life and we love it.”

That’s the energy I’m always working toward. And as a mom myself, I know firsthand how much easier said than done that is – but it’s worth leaning into.


Think About Where This Card Is Going to Live

A holiday card isn’t just something people read once. The ones worth keeping end up displayed – on a fridge, a mantle, a bulletin board. When you think about your card that way, it shifts what you’re going for a little.

Ask yourself:

  • Does this photo feel warm and inviting when you look at it?
  • Does it actually look like your family – your real expressions, your real energy?
  • Would you want to display it somewhere?

If the answer is yes to all three, you’ve got a keeper. That’s the bar I’m always aiming for.


Where Can I Print My Holiday Cards?

First of all, I would love to help you print your cards — reach out to me for pricing and design ideas!

But if you are more of a DIY person, these are the places I love most for cards:
– https://www.minted.com/
– https://www.simplytoimpress.com/
– https://www.artifactuprising.com/
– https://sugarpaper.com/collections/custom-holiday-cards


Ready to Make a Card Worth Keeping?

If you’ve got a holiday card in mind for this year, I’d love to help you make it happen. When you reach out, just let me know upfront that a card is the goal – that one detail helps me plan a session that gives you exactly what you need, whether it’s one standout image or a full set of options.

Families in Geneva, Batavia, St. Charles, and the surrounding Fox Valley area – I’m booking now for fall sessions. Let’s make something your family will want to look at for years, and that your friends and neighbors will absolutely keep on display.

Get in touch here and let’s start planning.

SHARE THIS POst

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *